Curated directory · Florida

Best real estate agents in Key West

The top-producing real estate agents in Key West, FL, ranked by recent sales from public profile data. Real production, real reviews — updated 2026-07-05.

AFBy Andre Fontaine
Mortgage Market Analyst
LVReviewed by Lena Voss
Housing Market Editor
Published May 20, 2026 · Updated July 8, 2026Editorial persona: WealthyBud bylines are editorial personas, not real individuals. Pages are produced by the WealthyBud research team from the public data cited on each page.
Browse Agents Teams Brokerages Key West market
Agents profiled12Ranked by recent production
Combined sales / 12 mo291Across profiled Key West agents
Avg client rating5.0/5From public client reviews

Who are the top real estate agents in Key West?

Ranked by recent production, Justyn Ewald of Expert Realty leads WealthyBud's Key West, FL list with about 88 sales in the last 12 months. The 12 agents profiled here closed 291 sales combined over 12 months, according to their public profiles as of 2026-07-05. Sales counts can include team production.

1

Justyn Ewald

Expert Realty · Key West, FL
$14K-$12MTop agent
88
Sales / 12 mo
$1M
Avg price
5★
133 reviews
2

Tommy Mack - Principal Broker

Coastal Collection Real Estate Inc · Key West, FL
$20K-$7.5MTop agent
42
Sales / 12 mo
$1.4M
Avg price
5★
136 reviews
3

Bascom L. Grooms IV

Bascom Grooms · Key West, FL
$110K-$4.2MTop agent
40
Sales / 12 mo
$1.1M
Avg price
5★
290 reviews
4

The Spottswood Team

Truman & Co. Real Estate Services · Key West, FL
$285K-$13M
34
Sales / 12 mo
$2.1M
Avg price
5★
40 reviews
5

Jimmy Lane

Island Life Realty Experts · Key West, FL
$290K-$2.1M
22
Sales / 12 mo
$935K
Avg price
5★
37 reviews
6

Donna Pezzi

Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty · Key West, FL
$48K-$3.9M
18
Sales / 12 mo
$1.2M
Avg price
5★
52 reviews
7

Justyn Ewald - Principal Broker

Expert Realty · Key West, FL
$160K-$3.7M
13
Sales / 12 mo
$1.1M
Avg price
5★
51 reviews
8

Vic Musmanno

Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co. · Key West, FL
$144K-$3.5M
10
Sales / 12 mo
$1M
Avg price
5★
169 reviews
9

Team Kaufelt

Truman & Company Real Estate Services · Key West, FL
$475K-$4M
9
Sales / 12 mo
$1.9M
Avg price
5★
40 reviews
10

Ellen Gvili

Ocean Sotheby's International Realty · Key West, FL
$250K-$8.5M
6
Sales / 12 mo
$2.6M
Avg price
5★
39 reviews
11

Leigh Ann Roach

Berkshire Hathaway Home Services - Knight & Gardner Realty · Key West, FL
$360K-$3.1M
5
Sales / 12 mo
$1.4M
Avg price
5★
41 reviews
12

Darrin Smith

Key West Luxury Real Estate Inc · Key West, FL
$540K-$4.6M
4
Sales / 12 mo
$1.1M
Avg price
5★
45 reviews
Market

Key West market report

Prices, trends and inventory for Key West.

View Licensing

Become an agent in Florida

Hours, exam and cost to get licensed.

Read Income

Agent salary in Florida

What Florida agents actually earn.

Read

How do you choose a real estate agent in Key West?

Shortlist two or three Key West agents whose recent sales match your price range, check that each holds an active Florida license, then interview them about pricing strategy, marketing and communication. Recent local production matters more than career totals.

Who is the top real estate agent in Key West?
By recent sales volume, Justyn Ewald of Expert Realty ranks among the highest-producing agents in Key West, FL, with about 88 sales in the last 12 months.
How were these Key West agents ranked?
Agents are ranked by recent production (sales in the trailing 12 months) using public agent profile data, then by total career sales and client reviews.
How do I choose a real estate agent in Key West?
Compare recent sales, average price point and client reviews, then interview two or three. The right Key West agent matches your price range and neighborhood, communicates well and has a current track record.
Agent names, brokerages and production stats are sourced from public agent profiles as of 2026-07-05 and may change. Sales counts can include full team production. This directory is informational and not an endorsement — verify current credentials before engaging an agent.